One of the original Xbox's best games was killed by its publisher, and the developers had no idea. Starbreeze veteran Jens Andersson says the team thought only the PS2 port was gone, and dropping Sony's weaker console is what let the Xbox game get finished. Plus, 25 years later, a modder got Halo running on a PS2. Barely.
The Chronicles of Riddick: Escape from Butcher Bay is one of the games that made the original Xbox feel like the future. It almost never came out at all. And the people making it didn’t know.
Jens Andersson, a lead designer and lead programmer on the 2004 game, told the FRVR Podcast that publisher Vivendi Universal Games pulled the plug on the entire project during development. “At that point in time, the project actually got cancelled by the game publisher, but the fun part is that we were never told,” he said. “And that was very intentional by the game publisher’s producer, Peter Wanat.”
The PS2 was the problem
Starbreeze was signed to make Butcher Bay for Xbox and PS2 at the same time, and the gap between the two machines showed fast. The Xbox version was finished in 18 months. “The PlayStation version was a couple of months behind,” Andersson said. As FRVR lays out, the Xbox had a better CPU, a much more powerful GPU, more advanced rendering features and a hard drive for caching, and Butcher Bay leaned hard on dynamic lighting and shaders. On PS2, all of that needed custom solutions just to keep up.
Andersson admits the whole game was in rough shape until late. He said it barely ran and looked bad “all the way up to beta,” and that neither Vivendi nor Universal had faith the team could finish. “It didn’t play well, it didn’t look well, it barely ran, and we were signed up to do both the PlayStation 2 and Xbox version,” he said.
So Starbreeze was given a choice: cut the PS2 version or lose the game. “Let’s give this game the best chance of releasing something, whatever that is, and that meant cancelling the PlayStation 2 game,” Andersson said. What the team didn’t know was that Vivendi had already cancelled everything. Wanat kept quiet on purpose and went around the publisher to Universal, which owned the Riddick license. Because Vivendi was contractually obliged to deliver a game, he got it un-cancelled. Most of Starbreeze only found out later. “When we were told this after the fact, we were like, ‘wow, we were this close to being out of a job’,” Andersson said, laughing. “But, you know, it did free up resources to finish the game, and we barely finished that game on time.”
The Xbox version is the one that lived
Here’s our take. Butcher Bay shipped on Xbox in June 2004, came to PC later that year, and, as VGC notes, still sits at 89 on Metacritic. It became the kind of game people point to when they talk about immersive first-person design and the movie tie-in that was actually great. All of that happened because the team stopped splitting its time with the weaker console and poured everything into the Xbox build. That’s not fanboy spin. That’s the developer’s own account of how the game survived.
To be fair, Andersson has a different what-if. “The PlayStation 2 version, internally, was starting to look pretty impressive,” he said. “Had that version not been cancelled, it might have ended up being the best looking PlayStation 2 game at the time. And had that happened, maybe the game would have made money and saved the studio.” Maybe. But by his own telling, the choice on the table was the PS2 port or no game at all, and the team was already scrambling to hit its date with one version. Keeping both looks a lot more like the path to nothing shipping. Starbreeze picked the Xbox, and the Xbox gave it a classic.
Riddick survived by cutting the PS2 port. Right call?
Vote and see what other Xbox fans think.
Like having a say? Get OnPoint Weekly or argue it out on Discord.
The story has a nice Xbox ending, too. Andersson is now design director at Xbox-owned MachineGames, which was founded by Starbreeze veterans and went on to make Wolfenstein and Indiana Jones and the Great Circle. He told the same podcast that Indiana Jones almost got a GTA-style wanted system. The Butcher Bay crew ended up home at Xbox. According to FRVR, Andersson believes Butcher Bay deserves a remaster or remake, though the game’s source code has been lost.
Halo on a PS2? It technically runs
If you need more proof of how far ahead the original Xbox was, a modder just provided it. Halo modder and creator Generalkidd has Halo: Combat Evolved running on a PS2 Slim, and Windows Central’s verdict is that the port is “semi-playable.” It’s slow, the visuals take a big hit, and the project is in its early days, but campaign and multiplayer are both in there.
Riddick: Escape From Butcher Bay Was Secretly Cancelled, and Cutting the PS2 Version Is What Saved the Xbox ClassicIt’s an impressive bit of hacking, and we love seeing it. It also shows the gap. As Windows Central points out, the original Xbox’s CPU was about 2.5 times faster than the PS2’s, with double the system memory. Twenty-five years later, Master Chief still makes Sony’s best-selling console sweat. What a time to be an Xbox fan, even in 2001.
Which original Xbox classic deserves a modern comeback? Let us know in the comments.
Image: Starbreeze / Vivendi Universal Games
Sources found below.




