From OnPointNew RAW IMPRESSIONS every weekFirst looks at the games Xbox fans care about.Subscribe on YouTube

Sony Is Pushing PS5 Owners to Sell Right Before GTA VI. Xbox Asked First, and Had the Better Pitch.

Official PlayStation 5 on a pawn-shop counter with a $400? price tag and a November 19 calendar, an Xbox controller and a PC monitor on the right, and the text SELL YOUR PS5 NOW?

Seventeen days before the biggest launch of the generation, the PlayStation app asked PS5 owners if they were ready to sell. Xbox ran its own trade-in first, but only one of these pitches lets you keep playing after the box is gone.

By CMoney · Nov 18, 2026 8:00 AM ET

Vote in our reader poll below

Grand Theft Auto VI lands Thursday. It’s the biggest launch of this console generation, and the PlayStation 5 is the only PlayStation that can play it. So you’d figure the last thing Sony would want right now is fewer PS5s plugged into TVs.

Then you look at what PS5 owners in the US found in the PlayStation app on November 2: “Trade in your PS5 console for up to $400.” UK owners got the same push for up to £300. Seventeen days before GTA VI, PlayStation was asking its own players if they were ready to sell.

First, what this actually is, because plenty of headlines got it wrong. Sony isn’t buying your console back. The money comes from Back Market, the refurbished-electronics marketplace that already runs PlayStation’s trade-in program in the US. You get a quote from one of the 250-plus refurbishers in Back Market’s network, ship the console free within 21 days, and the cash lands by direct deposit within five business days once it passes inspection. PlayStation’s part is the promotion, and Sony hasn’t said why it chose this moment to send it.

My take: the timing tells you more than the offer does. And the fine print tells you who the offer is really for.

The $400 is a ceiling with two controllers attached

Read the small print on Sony’s message. That $400 is “based on the average promised trade-in amount quoted for a PS5 Standard console with two or more controllers in Grade 0 condition,” using quotes from orders between August 23 and September 22. Grade 0 means flawless. And two or more controllers, when a new PS5 ships with one in the box.

Now put it next to what PlayStation charges today. Since April 2, a PS5 with a disc drive is $649.99, the Digital Edition is $599.99 and the PS5 Pro is $899.99. PlayStation Direct sells certified refurbished PS5s, and those still run well into the hundreds. Some players will do better selling on their own, too: Notebookcheck put used disc consoles with one DualSense at $450 to $500 on eBay, before fees and shipping.

So the best-case version of this deal is a pristine console and an extra controller for $400, in a market where getting back in costs hundreds refurbished or $649.99 new. That’s not a reward for loyal players. That’s a supply valve.

And honestly, it’s a smart one for Sony. The memory crunch has squeezed console supply and pushed prices up across the board, and the PS5 Pro is especially hard to find. A console sitting in a closet earns PlayStation nothing. Put it in a new owner’s hands before the holidays and that owner might buy GTA VI on the PS Store and sign up for PS Plus. Good business. Just don’t confuse good business with a good deal for you.

Xbox asked first, and that’s the point

Now, real talk, because I’m not going to pretend Xbox didn’t do this. In October, Microsoft emailed US owners who hadn’t played in a while, offering up to $375 in Best Buy credit for a Series X and up to $200 for a Series S. Xbox confirmed to Gizmodo the email was real. Metro’s headline on the PlayStation version literally said Sony was copying Xbox.

But read how Xbox pitched it: “Haven’t played on your console in a while? If you’ve moved on to Xbox on PC or another way to play Xbox games, it may be time to trade in your console to Best Buy for up to $375 back.”

That message only works because of what Xbox has become. It’s talking to people who still play Xbox, just not on that box. Between Xbox on PC, the cloud and Game Pass, the console isn’t the only way in. If it’s collecting dust because you play on PC now, passing it to somebody who will use it hurts nobody. When Microsoft raised the Series X to $799.99 in June, it said it was “working with retail partners on new programs to provide previously played consoles at lower prices.” Asha Sharma doubled down after earnings on October 28: “Console sales remain constrained by supply, with more demand than consoles available. We’re working to get more consoles into players’ hands, including through our expanded refurbishment program.”

Now read PlayStation’s version, as quoted by Metro: “If you’re ready to sell your console, you could soon receive a cash payment into your nominated bank account. Find out how much you could get today.” That’s the whole pitch. Cash. No “you can keep playing over here.” Because on PlayStation, GTA VI has no confirmed cloud streaming option, and even the PlayStation Portal needs a PS5 at home to play it. The box is the door. Sell it and you’re out until you buy another one.

That’s the difference I keep coming back to. Both companies want idle consoles back in circulation. Only one of them can honestly tell you that you’re not leaving when you hand the box over.

The best case for Sony, and why it doesn’t change my mind

PlayStation fans have a fair argument here, so let’s give it its due. Sony’s offer pays cash into your bank account. Xbox’s pays Best Buy gift cards. Up to $400 cash beats up to $375 in store credit, no question. And yes, a new Series X costs more than a new PS5 right now, and Xbox hardware revenue fell 14 percent in Microsoft’s latest quarter. Xbox isn’t winning a hardware price war this year, and I won’t pretend it is.

Reader poll

Sony's pushing a $400 PS5 trade-in right before GTA VI. Your move?

Vote and see what other Xbox fans think.

Sony's pushing a $400 PS5 trade-in right before GTA VI. Your move?

Like having a say? Get OnPoint Weekly or argue it out on Discord.

But a trade-in program isn’t really about the check. It’s a message about what the company thinks your console is. Sony’s message says the console is the product, so if you’re not using it, sell it to someone who will. Xbox’s message says the console is one way into Xbox, and if you’ve found another way, the box can go to somebody else.

You can see that same thinking in GTA VI week itself. Xbox Cloud Gaming streams Grand Theft Auto VI on day one, starting at 1 AM ET on November 19, to Xbox One and Xbox Series X|S consoles at Series S settings. You still buy the game, but owners of a console from 2013 are invited to the biggest launch of the decade. One company is finding ways to reach the hardware you already have. The other spent the run-up to that same launch asking whether you’d like to sell yours.

What to actually do before Thursday

If you’re on PlayStation and planning to play GTA VI there, keep your console. Selling a PS5 the day before the game you’ve waited years for, just to buy back in at $649.99, is the worst trade on the board.

If your PS5 really has been gathering dust and GTA VI isn’t changing that, get the Back Market quote and compare it with a private sale before you ship anything. That $400 is for a flawless console with two controllers, not whatever’s under your TV.

And if you’re one of those PS5 owners who’s been eyeing the other side? Xbox already told you how it feels about the box. It’s a way in, not a cage. Join this side.

Would you take Sony’s $400 right before GTA VI, or is your PS5 staying put? Let me know in the comments.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Chat