From OnPointJoin the crew on DiscordTalk Xbox news the second it drops.Join Discord

GTA 6 Hits 99 on Metacritic, Tying Zelda’s All-Time Record as Critics Crown Rockstar’s Masterpiece

Official Rockstar Games Grand Theft Auto VI key art of Jason and Lucia on a dock in Vice City, overlaid with a 99 Metascore and the hook TIED FOR NO. 1

The Grand Theft Auto VI review embargo is gone and the verdict is close to unanimous: a 99 Metascore, a 98 on OpenCritic, and perfect scores from Xbox outlets that played it on Series X. Here's what the biggest critics said, the few knocks they found, and where Xbox players stand one day before launch.

By OnPoint 4 Gamers · Nov 18, 2026 6:28 AM ET

Vote in our reader poll below

Thirteen years of waiting, and the critics just handed Rockstar a near-perfect report card. The Grand Theft Auto VI review embargo lifted at 6:00 AM ET this morning, and as of 6:20 AM ET the game holds a 99 Metascore on Metacritic based on 115 critic reviews, every single one of them positive. Metacritic’s Xbox Series X listing sits at 99 as well, from 10 reviews. Over on OpenCritic, it has a 98 Top Critic Average with 100% of critics recommending it across 59 reviews.

That 99 puts GTA 6 in company that basically does not exist. On Metacritic’s all-time chart, only one game sits at 99: The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time, from 1998. Everything else tops out at 98, including Rockstar’s own Grand Theft Auto IV. Scores can still move a point as more reviews land today, but right now GTA 6 is tied for the highest Metascore ever recorded. That’s crazy. That’s literally crazy.

YouTube player

What the critics said

This is the part that jumps out to us: the Xbox outlets that played it on Series X are as loud as anybody. Pure Xbox’s Fraser Gilbert says his 10 is the first he has given in a decade-long career, and Windows Central basically asked for a bigger scale. Here are the scores from the outlets that matter most, with a line from each review.

  • Pure Xbox (Fraser Gilbert): 10/10, reviewed on Xbox Series X. “Somehow, GTA 6 lives up to the hype. Rockstar Games has crafted the most incredible open world I’ve ever experienced in a video game.” Read the review
  • Windows Central (Jez Corden): 5/5, reviewed on Xbox Series X. “A game so good I asked our tech team if I could somehow give it 11/10.” Read the review
  • TheXboxHub (Neil Watton): 5/5, reviewed on Xbox Series X|S. “Rip up your schedule and book those days off work. Grand Theft Auto VI will consume your life.” Read the review
  • Edge: 10/10. Jason and Lucia “form one of the great partnerships in entertainment: beautiful and deadly.” Edge’s verdict on Metacritic
  • Eurogamer (Chris Tapsell): 5/5. “A game of opposites and awe, minute detail and impossible scale, Rockstar pushes back the horizon of video games once again with GTA 6.” Read the review
  • GamesRadar+ (Josh West): 5/5. “GTA 6 is the highest-fidelity sandbox of its generation.” Read the review
  • VGC (Jordan Middler): 5/5. “Grand Theft Auto 6 is a modern masterpiece.” Read the review
  • The Guardian (Keza MacDonald): 5/5. “Rockstar has created the most extraordinarily, indulgently detailed virtual world that we have yet seen.” Read the review
  • TechRadar (Rob Dwiar): 5/5. “Grand Theft Auto 6 is an absolute triumph.” Read the review
  • DualShockers (Steve Hannley): 10/10. “Put simply, this is one of the largest and most ambitious games ever created.” Read the review
  • Wccftech (Alessio Palumbo): 9.6/10. “this is as spectacular as an open world console game can get.” Read the review
  • TheSixthAxis (Aran Suddi): 9/10. “Grand Theft Auto VI is a great game that lives up to so much of the hype and expectations.” Read the review

The Verge’s Andrew Webster, whose outlet doesn’t give scores, landed in the same place, writing that Rockstar has crafted “the new standard-bearer for open-world games.”

The knocks, such as they are

Nobody is calling this a flawless game, and the criticism is worth knowing before you clear your week. The Guardian’s Keza MacDonald warns that all that realism comes with “complex controls” and adds, “This can be a frustrating game at times: unpredictable, laborious, unwieldy and, occasionally, unfair.” TheSixthAxis, one of the lowest scores so far at 9/10, feels “the need to constantly raise the stakes across such a long story lessens its impact.” VGC lists “occasional frame-rate issues in dense zones” as its one con, and Pure Xbox’s Fraser Gilbert says the story, while it kept him invested, is “not my favourite from all the GTAs.”

Our read: when the worst thing critics can say is that the controls take some getting used to and the story runs long, that’s not a crack in the armor. That’s a game so big it’s hard to keep every thread tight for 60 hours, and almost every reviewer says the payoff is worth it.

How it runs on Xbox

The question every Xbox player has been asking since Rockstar confirmed 30 FPS on every console: how does it actually feel? The two biggest Xbox outlets say it feels great. Windows Central’s Jez Corden, who played primarily on Xbox Series X, says the game “opts for the ‘dreaded’ 30 FPS” but “that 30 FPS is buttery smooth and doesn’t present as choppy,” and that he “didn’t notice frame dips or struggling delivery, even when driving supercars at maximum speed on the freeway.” Corden adds he hasn’t tested Series S yet and plans to follow up after launch.

Pure Xbox calls it “definitely a stunner on Xbox Series X,” with “occasional pop-in” that’s “minimal” and only “very rare” big frame rate drops in the most intensive sequences. Gilbert played about 30 hours on a VRR-enabled display and around 10 without one, and says he was “perfectly happy with the performance in both cases.” TheXboxHub’s Neil Watton reports “zero lag, tearing, or slowdown experienced” across close to 100 hours.

Reader poll

GTA 6 is sitting at a 99 on Metacritic. Did the critics get it right?

Vote and see what other Xbox fans think.

GTA 6 is sitting at a 99 on Metacritic. Did the critics get it right?

Like having a say? Get OnPoint Weekly or argue it out on Discord.

That lines up with what we’ve been saying for weeks: a locked, smooth 30 in a world this dense beats a shaky 60, and Red Dead Redemption 2 proved Rockstar knows how to make 30 feel right. Add the Dolby Vision support listed on the Xbox Series X|S case, and Series X looks like a great place to live in Leonida.

When you can play on Xbox

GTA 6 launches Thursday, November 19 on Xbox Series X|S, unlocking at midnight local time in every region, per Rockstar. New Zealand already hit midnight at 6:00 AM ET today, which is why the New Zealand trick is suddenly the hottest thing on your Xbox dashboard.

And if you’re still on an Xbox One, you’re not left out. Per Xbox Wire, GTA 6 is playable on day one through Xbox Cloud Gaming on Xbox One and Xbox Series X|S, starting at 1 AM ET on November 19, using Xbox Series S graphics settings. It’s the first move in Xbox’s new 10-year partnership with Take-Two, and getting a game reviewers are calling a generational masterpiece onto a 2013 console is a gigantic W for Xbox.

Our take

We called this the biggest review day of the generation when the embargo date surfaced, and it delivered. A 99 is the kind of score that ends arguments, and the fact that the Xbox reviewers who played it on Series X are right at the top of the pile should settle any worry about how it plays on our side. It already has a Game of the Year nomination at The Game Awards, and after this morning it’s hard to see anyone else as the favorite.

OnPoint hasn’t reviewed GTA 6 yet, and we’re not going to pretend otherwise. CMoney plays it live on We Doin’ It LIVE on Thursday, November 19 at 8 PM ET, GTA 6 launch night, on YouTube at @OnPoint4Gamers. Come hang out, see Leonida on Xbox for yourself, and let us know in the chat if the critics got it right.

Image: Rockstar Games

Sources found below.

Sources found below

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Sources

Chat