From OnPointJoin the crew on DiscordTalk Xbox news the second it drops.Join Discord

GameStop’s CEO Says All-Digital Games Have Hurt Consumers, as GTA 6 Ships as a Code in a Box

Official Grand Theft Auto VI cover art collage of Lucia and Jason with the VI logo, plus a white-on-black OnPoint bar reading A CODE IN A BOX

Ryan Cohen told Bloomberg that when you buy a game, you should be able to sell it, trade it or lend it. He also said GameStop is "selling a lot" of GTA 6 anyway, even though the box is just a download code.

By OnPoint 4 Gamers · Nov 19, 2026 4:25 PM ET

Vote in our reader poll below

Grand Theft Auto VI is the biggest game in the world this week, and the copy you can still buy in a store is not a disc. It’s a box with a download code in it. GameStop CEO Ryan Cohen just said the quiet part out loud.

“When you buy a game, you should be able to sell it, trade it or lend it to a friend,” Cohen told Bloomberg, as quoted by Quartz and GameSpot. “Unquestionably, the decision to move to all digital has hurt consumers, and it’s also hurt GameStop.” He would not name a company, Quartz reports, and a Take-Two spokesperson declined to comment. Asked about presales, Cohen didn’t bother dressing it up, as quoted by Quartz: “It’s a code in a box. I mean, we’re selling a lot of it.”

That is the whole launch-day argument in two sentences. Players want something they can trade or lend. Retailers want the used-game business that comes with a disc. Publishers would rather sell a new copy every time. Cohen told Bloomberg he has talked with “the obvious” publishers about that, and then spelled out why they don’t like trade-ins: “Of course they don’t like [trade-ins] because removing a used copy eliminates an alternative to buying new. They’re taking away competition.”

He has a business reason to care. Quartz, citing Bloomberg, says pre-owned and refurbished products made up 22% of GameStop’s sales in the quarter that ended August 1, about $171 million, which is a 32% drop from the prior year. That is a real hole in the company’s old model, and GTA 6 does not fill it. Once you redeem the code, the case on your shelf does not go back across the GameStop counter as a playable copy for someone else.

We’ve been making this point all week. Our no-disc column already argued that the fight around GTA 6 is storage and access, not whether the cardboard is “physical.” A code-in-box copy still has to download. It still wants a huge chunk of free space. And if the code is missing or already used, you don’t have a disc to fall back on, which is why boxed-copy complaints have been part of launch week. Cohen is not revealing a new format. He is putting a public number and a public quote on a format Rockstar already chose.

Reader poll

GTA 6 comes in a box, but the box is just a code. Your take?

Vote and see what other Xbox fans think.

GTA 6 comes in a box, but the box is just a code. Your take?

Like having a say? Get OnPoint Weekly or argue it out on Discord.

The wider backdrop is the same shift. Sony has said it will stop manufacturing physical discs for new PlayStation titles starting in January 2028, according to Bloomberg as cited by Quartz. Cohen also told Bloomberg he has met with Rep. Ritchie Torres, who is backing a bill that would require companies to keep games playable after purchase. “When you pay for a game, you should own it,” Torres said in an October statement, per that same writeup. That’s a policy fight for another day. Today’s fact is simpler: the biggest launch of the generation is being sold in a box, and the thing in the box is a code.

Image: Rockstar Games

Sources found below.

Sources found below

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Sources

Chat