GTA VI's nomination is completely within the rules, and Xbox walked out of nominations day with eight. But Gears has six weeks of proof in players' hands, and the one award fans pick on their own opens after GTA launches.
Two days before anybody can buy it, Grand Theft Auto VI is a Game of the Year nominee. It also leads The Game Awards 2026 with eight nominations. Gears of War: E-Day, a game Xbox players have been living in since early October, picked up three nominations and no seat at the big table.
I know how that looks to a lot of Xbox fans, and some people are already calling the show “rigged,” as Kotaku put it. Here’s my take: it isn’t rigged, and GTA VI isn’t the villain. But this nomination shows exactly where Game of the Year season tilts, toward the game that owns the conversation, judged by people who got to play it before the rest of us. And Xbox fans have the perfect answer sitting right there on the calendar.
The rules let GTA in, fair and square
The Game Awards keeps it simple. According to its official FAQ, a game has to be on sale by Friday, November 20, at 9 PM PT. GTA VI launches Thursday, so it clears the bar by a day. Nominees come from a jury of more than 100 media and creator outlets, each turning in an unranked top five per category, and the rules openly say publishers “may provide advance or pre-release access to games for critical evaluation.”
Geoff Keighley also shot down the idea that the date moved for Rockstar. “Our dates have been very set every year. It’s the same calendar that we have,” he told Variety last week.
Reviews haven’t even posted yet. Insider NateTheHate said back in October that Rockstar had started sending review code with a November 18 embargo, and Insider Gaming says copies went out at the end of October. Rockstar hasn’t confirmed any of it. If that’s right, a lot of jurors have had weeks with the game. So this nod most likely reflects real playtime from people holding the code. That’s legit, and I’m not going to pretend otherwise.
The problem is the head start
Here’s the part that bugs me. Fan voting opened today, the second the nominees dropped, and fans count for 10% of the result in every category. Right now that 10% is a vote on trailers and hype for the biggest game on the ballot, and a vote on six weeks of actual play for Gears. Same ballot, completely different evidence.
And this keeps happening. Last month the Golden Joysticks left E-Day off their 12-game Ultimate Game of the Year shortlist while finding room for Phantom Blade Zero, which wasn’t out yet and launched after that award’s cutoff. Their rules carve out exceptions for games judges played early. Two award shows, one month, same pattern: the games with the biggest pre-release momentum get the head start, and the game that already proved itself waits in line.
Gears doesn’t need hype. It has proof. It’s sitting at an 87 on Metacritic. I gave the campaign a 9.5 and called it “a must-play prequel that actually needed to exist,” and I came out of it feeling like I knew Marcus and Dom better than I did after the original trilogy. Then I gave the multiplayer a 9.5 too, because once you’re with a normal squad it’s really dope, and winning a Demolition round felt glorious. That’s not a promise. That’s a game people have been playing since October 6.
I’m not saying any of the six nominees doesn’t belong. Six slots is a brutal squeeze in a stacked year. I’m saying a game that already delivered deserved to be measured against them on the same footing, and right now it isn’t.
Read those eight nominations again
Now the fun part, because Xbox had a strong day. Xbox Wire says Xbox’s studios “have earned eight nominations across multiple categories,” and look where they landed: Best Action Game, Best Multiplayer, Best Sports/Racing and Innovation in Accessibility. Those are the categories that judge how a game feels in your hands.
Gears is up for three of them, Best Action Game, Best Multiplayer and Innovation in Accessibility, which makes it Xbox’s most-nominated game of the year. Forza Horizon 6 is up for Best Sports/Racing and Innovation in Accessibility. Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 4 sits right next to Gears in Best Multiplayer, so Xbox owns two of those six spots. Fable is in Most Anticipated Game, and Minecraft’s Create Aeronautics is up for Best User Creation. The one I wish had made it is Halo: Campaign Evolved, my 10 out of 10, which came away empty. That’s a conversation for another day.
Here’s the detail I love: Gears and GTA never share a category. Not one. GTA’s eight are spread across Game of the Year, direction, narrative, art, music, audio, performance and Action/Adventure. Gears is fighting Ace Combat 8, Onimusha: Way of the Sword, Phantom Blade Zero and Saros in Best Action Game, and Big Walk, Marathon, Meccha Chameleon, Orbitals and its Xbox teammate Modern Warfare 4 in Best Multiplayer. Rockstar’s juggernaut isn’t standing in its way anywhere. Those trophies are there for the taking.
Players' Voice opens Nov 30. Who gets your vote?
Vote and see what other Xbox fans think.
Like having a say? Get OnPoint Weekly or argue it out on Discord.
The rematch is Players’ Voice
This is where Xbox fans get the last word. The Game Awards runs a separate award called Players’ Voice, the fan vote, as Polygon calls it. Per the official Players’ Voice page, round one opens November 30 with 30 nominees and you vote for 10. Round two cuts it to 10 and you pick five. Round three is five games and one vote. Anything that ships by November 30 is eligible.
Think about that timing. By November 30, GTA VI will have been in players’ hands for 11 days. Gears will have been out for almost two months. Players’ Voice is the first moment this awards season where both games get judged by people who actually played them. That’s the fair fight. If E-Day makes the 30, and that list isn’t out yet, that’s the Gears vs. GTA rematch, and it’s 100% on us.
So here’s the plan. Vote for Gears in Best Action Game and Best Multiplayer right now at TheGameAwards.com/nominees, and get your ballot in before December 9 at 9 PM ET. In a tight race, 10% can matter. If you haven’t played E-Day yet, Xbox Wire points out it’s on Game Pass, so you’ve got time to see for yourself before Players’ Voice opens. Then play GTA VI on Thursday, have a blast in Leonida, and come back November 30 ready to vote with both games under your belt.
GTA VI earned its invitation on the strength of what jurors saw early. Gears earned its three nominations on six weeks of everybody playing it. When the fans finally get the whole say, I like our chances.
Who’s getting your Players’ Voice vote, Gears or GTA? Let me know in the comments.




