IGN put the cheapest current console next to the most powerful one and the internet lost it. Here's what the footage actually shows, where the little Xbox wins on value, and where it still dips.
Nobody expected this matchup to be a conversation. On one side, the Xbox Series S, the smallest and cheapest console of this generation. On the other, the PS5 Pro, the most powerful console you can buy. IGN put Grand Theft Auto VI on both, side by side, and titled the result “Closer Than You’d Think.” The internet agreed.
IGN posted the comparison on X Thursday night at 9:10 PM ET with a simple pitch: “We compared GTA 6 gameplay performance on the Xbox Series S to the PS5 Pro, and the results may surprise you!” By Friday afternoon that post had passed 4 million views and 21,000 likes.
The video itself is nearly nine minutes of matched gameplay with no narration, just the two versions running the same moments. IGN’s description lays out the premise: “With the Xbox Series S representing the cheapest entry point into the world of Leonida, and PS5 Pro representing the most powerful, we put the two head to head!”
Xbox’s Aaron Greenberg had one reaction
Aaron Greenberg, Xbox’s VP of Games Marketing, quote-posted IGN’s comparison at 1:44 AM ET Friday with a DMX-flavored victory lap: “S Gon Give It Ta Ya! 🤯💚” He also reshared The Verge’s Tom Warren praising how GTA 6 looks on Series S, plus a post from French outlet Jeuxvideo.com about Series S owners being pleasantly surprised by the game.
It’s a fun moment for Xbox, and honestly it’s earned. Series S has spent years as the console people assumed would hold this generation back. Instead, on the biggest launch in gaming history, it’s sitting next to a PS5 Pro in a viral comparison, and the replies are full of Series S owners celebrating.
What the footage shows
The reason the comparison lands is that Series S didn’t lose the stuff that makes GTA 6 look like GTA 6. Digital Foundry’s full console breakdown found that “all major graphical features from PS5 and Series X are also maintained on Series S, including strand-based hair, RT reflections and RTGI.” Series S renders at 720p and uses AMD’s machine-learning FSR 4 to rebuild that into roughly 1080p. Digital Foundry says, “From what we understand, this is the first shipping game on Series consoles to use the new upscaler.” We broke that down in full in our Series S FSR 4 story.
The other big equalizer is the frame rate cap. Rockstar targets 30 FPS on every console, PS5 Pro included, and there’s no 60 FPS mode anywhere. When the most expensive console in the room is chasing the same 30 FPS target as the cheapest one, the gap in a side-by-side shrinks to resolution, sharpness and polish rather than a whole different feel.
And Leonida itself doesn’t shrink on the little Xbox. Digital Foundry says “the full-fat CPU and SSD on the Series S mean that the scale and scope of Leonida isn’t affected.” Same traffic, same crowds, same map.
That’s our read on why this clip went viral: Series S owners are getting the full GTA 6, with ray-traced lighting on, on a console that was built to be the budget option. For the millions of people who own one, that’s the headline.
Where the PS5 Pro still wins
Let’s keep it real, because the footage only tells part of the story. PS5 Pro is the best-looking and smoothest console version, and everyone who has tested it says so. Digital Foundry calls the Pro “the best option available, with solid frame-rates, 4K-like image quality and a noticeable visual upgrade thanks to ray-traced shadows.” The Pro renders at 1440p and upscales to 4K with Sony’s PSSR, and it’s the only console with ray-traced shadows.
IGN’s written analysis, from its team that played the opening half hour on all four consoles, lines up with that. IGN found Series S holds a fairly steady 30 FPS through the prologue and the start of Chapter 1, with occasional drops down to 24 FPS, and camera turns that slip to 27 or 28 FPS. It also noted more jagged edges on Series S. On PS5 Pro, IGN didn’t notice a single dip in that stretch.
Digital Foundry, testing much deeper into the game, is tougher on the small Xbox. It says Series S has “the loosest 30fps lock,” and that “Series S often lies in a 25-30fps no-man’s-land” during heavier play. Firefights and car chases push it into the mid-20s, and blowing up a pile of cars with a grenade launcher can drag it lower. Kotaku pointed out a few seconds in DF’s footage where an explosive shootout hit 18 to 19 FPS. Base PS5 isn’t spotless either, as we covered in our base PS5 frame drops report.
After seeing GTA 6 on Series S next to PS5 Pro, what's your verdict?
Vote and see what other Xbox fans think.
Like having a say? Get OnPoint Weekly or argue it out on Discord.
Tom Warren, who packed a Series S for a trip, summed up both sides in one post: “it’s legit impressive how good GTA 6 looks on the Xbox Series S. The frame rate drops well below 30fps at times, but Rockstar really didn’t sacrifice the visual quality here.”
One more Xbox detail worth knowing: Digital Foundry notes that “Xbox consoles can run the game in a 120Hz VRR container as an OS-level feature, which allows for a slightly smoother experience.” PlayStation’s system VRR only kicks in above 48 FPS, so it doesn’t help a 30 FPS game. If you’re on Series S with a VRR TV, that setting is worth turning on.
The bottom line
Series S is not a PS5 Pro, and nobody serious is claiming it is. If you want the cleanest GTA 6, the Pro is it, and Series X is the strongest Xbox option. But the reason this comparison blew up is that the gap is a lot smaller than people expected. Series S runs the full game, with the full lighting system and the full world, on hardware that was designed as the entry-level box. That’s a credit to Rockstar’s work and a big win for every Series S owner who wondered if they’d get left behind. Greenberg has a point. The S gave it to ya.
And if you’re still on Xbox One, GTA 6 is playable there too through Xbox Cloud Gaming on console.
Image: IGN / Rockstar Games
Sources found below.





