Circana's October U.S. chart shows Sony's biggest PS5 exclusive of 2026 sliding 13 spots in its second month. In the same report, Gears of War: E-Day debuted at number two even though it launched day one on Game Pass.
One month ago, Marvel’s Wolverine was the best-selling game in America. Now it isn’t even in the top ten. Circana’s October 2026 U.S. report shows Insomniac’s PS5 exclusive falling from first place in September all the way to 14th, and the analyst who runs the chart said it plainly.
“Marvel’s Wolverine dropped from 1st in Sept to 14th in Oct, ranks in top 15 YTD,” Circana’s Mat Piscatella posted on Bluesky Thursday, as reported by Push Square. He added that the year-to-date race is tight: “On the YTD charts, less than $10M separates 8th place from 13th.” Push Square puts Wolverine 15th for 2026 overall, down from 11th after September.
Two big October launches, two very different months
Here is the part Xbox fans are going to point at. The October top ten, published by Nintendo Everything with Piscatella’s data, opens with two Microsoft games: Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 4 at number one and Gears of War: E-Day at number two, ahead of Star Wars: Galactic Racer, EA Sports FC 27 and NBA 2K27.
That E-Day number deserves a second look. The game launched October 6 on Xbox Series X|S and PC and was on Game Pass from day one, so a huge share of players never had to buy it to play it. It still finished as the second best-selling game in the country for its launch month, and we gave it a 9.5. If anyone still believes Game Pass kills sales for big first-party games, October is a pretty loud answer.
Wolverine went the other way. Sony told investors earlier this month that the game had sold 2.4 million units as of November 4, about 50 days after its September 15 launch, according to Gematsu. For comparison, Sony said Insomniac’s Marvel’s Spider-Man 2 sold more than 2.5 million copies in its first 24 hours back in 2023. We broke down that gap when Sony’s numbers landed.
Is a second-month drop normal?
To be fair to Wolverine, big games usually do most of their business at launch, and most of them slide in month two. Push Square, which scored the game 8/10, said as much, noting Sony “seemed relatively satisfied” with the 2.4 million figure. A September game also had to fight a stacked October that included Modern Warfare 4, E-Day, Galactic Racer and the annual sports releases.
But a drop from first to 14th is not a gentle slide. That is a game falling out of the conversation the moment new releases arrived, and it lines up with what we saw at The Game Awards, where PlayStation was shut out of Game of the Year. Push Square also points out that Sony is discounting Wolverine for Black Friday to stir up interest, and with Grand Theft Auto VI now out, the road back up the chart in November looks rough.
Wolverine fell from No. 1 to No. 14. What happened?
Vote and see what other Xbox fans think.
Like having a say? Get OnPoint Weekly or argue it out on Discord.
Our read: this is less about one game and more about where the momentum sits right now. Xbox Series dollar sales were up 42% in the same report, the biggest jump of any console, and we covered that here. Microsoft owned the top two spots, and E-Day got there while sitting on Game Pass. Sony’s big fall exclusive, a Marvel game from the studio behind Spider-Man, is sitting at 14. PlayStation fans can fairly argue Wolverine had its launch month and did fine. Xbox fans can fairly argue that E-Day did better while being available on a subscription. Both of those things are in the data, and only one of them is a good look.
Image: Sony Interactive Entertainment / Insomniac Games and Xbox Game Studios / The Coalition
Sources found below.




