From OnPointNext show: Night ShiftFriday 8 PM ET on YouTubeSet a reminder

Xbox Got 29% More Expensive and Still Outgrew PS5 in October. The “Xbox Is Dead” Crowd Has a Math Problem.

Official Xbox Series X console and controller on a dark background, with overlays reading UNITS +10%, +29%, and PS5 +5%, and an OnPoint hook reading STILL BUYING.

Circana’s October numbers show Xbox Series unit sales up 10% in the U.S. even though the average Xbox now costs 29% more, double PS5’s unit growth and one month after Xbox spending was in the red. Everybody’s busy explaining away the 42%. They’re missing the number that actually matters.

By OnPoint 4 Gamers · Nov 20, 2026 10:30 AM ET · Updated 1:51 PM ET

Vote in our reader poll below

For about three years now, every conversation about Xbox hardware has started at a funeral. Sales are down, the price went up, Microsoft is just a publisher now, turn the lights off on your way out. So excuse me for enjoying this one.

Circana’s October 2026 U.S. sales report came out Thursday, and Xbox Series dollar sales were up 42% compared to October 2025. PS5 was up 20%. Switch 2 was down 11%. Kotaku called it “a sort of dramatic rise that I feel like I haven’t seen in a while from Xbox,” and Kotaku’s post about it blew past 1,300 likes on X. That tells you how long Xbox fans have been waiting for a chart like this.

The second that number dropped, the replies showed up with the asterisk. It’s just the price. And yes, Circana’s Mat Piscatella said it himself: “Higher pricing was the primary driver of the dollar sales growth on both PlayStation 5 and Xbox Series.” The average Xbox Series sold for 29% more than it did a year ago. I’m not going to pretend 42% means Xbox sold 42% more consoles. It didn’t.

Here’s what people are missing

The price isn’t the excuse. The price is what makes the real number impressive.

Xbox Series unit sales were up 10% year over year in October. Not dollars. Boxes. And that happened while the average price jumped 29%. On the PlayStation side, PS5 units grew 5% on a 13% price bump. So Xbox took the bigger price hit and still grew units at twice PS5’s rate.

Piscatella explained to Kotaku why that matters: “Higher pricing generally represses unit volume no matter what product or category one’s looking at (be it grocery, clothes or video game stuff).” That’s basic economics. Raise the price that much and fewer people buy. Kotaku even pointed out that in past months, Circana noted rising prices were actively discouraging people from buying Xboxes. In October, people bought more anyway. “People did buy more units of Xbox Series this October despite the raised price,” Piscatella said.

When people pay more for something and still buy more of it, that’s called demand, and that’s exactly what the “Xbox is dead” crowd swore wasn’t there.

What changed between September and October

Look at the month before. In September, per GameSpot’s rundown of Circana’s data, Xbox Series dollar sales dropped 2% while PS5 grew 43%. One month later, Xbox went from negative to the biggest dollar growth of the three big consoles.

So what happened in between? Gears of War: E-Day launched October 6 on Xbox Series X|S and PC, and it debuted at number two on Circana’s October best-sellers chart, right behind Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 4. Microsoft-owned games held the top two spots. And Piscatella gave the credit plainly: “It’s no secret that Xbox Series hardware sales have struggled in recent years. Gears and GTA may have provided at least a temporary reprieve.”

Read that again. Gears. An Xbox exclusive moved Xbox consoles. For years we were told that doesn’t work anymore, that Xbox games don’t sell Xbox hardware, that Microsoft should give up and put everything everywhere.

Jez Corden at Windows Central, writing about these same numbers, called Xbox’s “pivot back to exclusive console games a bit questionable from a purely fiscal standpoint,” because Microsoft hasn’t been able to get the parts it needs to meet demand. I respect Jez, but October is the first hard evidence on the other side of that argument. He also wrote that he’d heard from trusted sources Xbox was enjoying a boom in global hardware sales over the summer, and that global supply has been “anaemic.” If he’s right, then the problem is getting boxes on shelves, not getting people to want them. That’s a very different story than the one y’all have been told.

Reader poll

Xbox units grew 10% at a 29% higher price. Why?

Vote and see what other Xbox fans think.

Xbox units grew 10% at a 29% higher price. Why?

Like having a say? Get OnPoint Weekly or argue it out on Discord.

The fair part

I’ll give the other side its due. Piscatella warned that “percentages are always tricky because the lower the number is the easier it is to get to a higher percentage change,” and Xbox was coming off a rough stretch. Switch 2 was still the best-selling console in the U.S. in October in both units and dollars, according to VGChartz, and PS5 was second in every measure. I’m not telling you Xbox won the month. I’m telling you the direction flipped, and it flipped on the back of Xbox’s own games.

And remember, Circana’s October window ran from October 4 to October 31. Grand Theft Auto VI didn’t launch until November 19. Every one of those extra Xbox sales came from people buying for Gears, or getting ready for GTA 6, before the biggest launch in years had even arrived. Piscatella already said “all bets are off for everyone in November across Ocarina, GTA and even WoW Forever.” November is when GTA actually hits the chart.

Why this matters for what’s next

This is the part I want people to sit with heading into the Project Helix era. The whole case against Xbox hardware has been built on one idea: people won’t pay up for an Xbox, so stop trying. October says they will, when the games are there. Gears gave them a reason. GTA 6 gave them a deadline. Prices went up and units went up anyway. That’s a W, plain and simple.

That’s the blueprint. Keep putting big Xbox games like Gears on Xbox, keep making Xbox a place to play the biggest games day one, and the box sells, even at a price nobody loves. The “Xbox is dead” crowd spent the week explaining away a 42%. They should have been looking at the 10%.

Image: Xbox

Sources found below.

Sources found below

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Sources

Chat