As of 6:34 PM ET, Grand Theft Auto VI still has a 99 Metascore from 152 critic reviews, all of them positive. The user score on Metacritic's PlayStation 5 listing is 5.3 from 15,730 ratings, up from 4.9 earlier Friday. Some outlets are calling it a review bomb. Players are also sounding off about the 30 FPS cap, pacing and bugs, and both of those things can be true at once.
Critics called Grand Theft Auto VI a masterpiece. The review roundup is still sitting at a 99 Metascore. Players, at least the ones scoring it on Metacritic, are telling a much messier story, and the user number has already moved tonight.
As of 6:34 PM ET on November 20, Metacritic’s PlayStation 5 listing shows a 99 Metascore, Universal Acclaim, from 152 critic reviews, every one of them positive. The user score on that same page is 5.3, Mixed or Average, from 15,730 ratings: 45% positive (7,087), 8% mixed (1,259) and 47% negative (7,384). The Xbox Series X page shows the same 5.3 user score, from 14,881 ratings, with critics also at 99 from 14 reviews.
The score opened ugly, and it is still moving
At 4:29 PM ET, GTA News posted a screenshot of a 4.9 user score, Generally Unfavorable, from 2,507 ratings, set against that same 99 from 152 critics.
Twenty minutes later, CharlieIntel posted a similar shot: 4.9 from 2,466 ratings. “Grand Theft Auto VI is being review bombed on Metacritic after the site allowed user scores to be added,” CharlieIntel wrote.
GameRant still had it at 4.9 at 5:09 PM ET. TheGamer had it at 5.1 at 5:47 PM ET. Nicholas De Leon, writing up The Raytrace at 5:30 PM ET, said the PS5 user score was 4.9 from 4,900 ratings “as of Friday afternoon.” By 6:34 PM ET, the PS5 listing had grown past 15,000 ratings and the average had climbed to 5.3, enough for Metacritic to flip the label to Mixed or Average. This number is not done moving.
One side says review bomb. The other side has real complaints.
CharlieIntel, TheGamer and GameRant have all used the review-bomb framing. We are not calling it a confirmed review bomb. A flood of low scores is not proof that every low score is fake. Metacritic holds user reviews for a short window after launch, so the first wave landed about a day after the game came out. Even players who jumped in early would have a hard time finishing a game this size. TheGamer said the user section was “absolutely flooded” with negative reviews, including politically charged attacks on the story and the relationship mechanics, plus reviews from people who admit they “haven’t even played the game.” GameRant pointed at a pile of “woke” and “DEI” complaints that have nothing to do with how the game plays.
What's actually driving GTA 6's user score right now?
Vote and see what other Xbox fans think.
Like having a say? Get OnPoint Weekly or argue it out on Discord.
That is not the whole picture. Buried in the same score are complaints we have already been writing about, because they are real. Rockstar locked every console at 30 FPS, PS5 Pro included, and said even that machine “is not powerful enough” for a 60 FPS mode. Our Series S vs PS5 Pro breakdown laid out the same cap on both platforms: the world is dense, the simulation is heavy, and the frame rate is the trade. Players are also talking about dips under 30, a slower opening some compare to Red Dead Redemption 2, and bugs in a game this big. TheGamer flagged genuine gripes about console performance, the control scheme and returning franchise features that are not in this release. GameRant, even while calling the score a review bomb, said some of the mixed and negative reviews “have merit” once you set the culture-war stuff aside, especially on that slower, more realistic feel.
So no, 5.3 is not a clean player verdict, and 99 is not the only score that matters. One number is a critic consensus that has barely budged. The other is a day-old user average that opened at 4.9, is already at 5.3, and is being pulled by a pile-on and by launch complaints that are not imaginary. None of this changes the other fact of this launch. Take-Two says the game did $3.79 billion in day-one retail sales, the biggest entertainment launch in history. People are playing it. The fight is over how to score it.
Image: Rockstar Games
Sources found below.





